Bag and compact filters may both be candidates for an air handling unit. Identical face dimensions do not make them automatically interchangeable. Selection has to address the filtration requirement, the housing geometry and the available fan capacity together.
This guide works through that decision in order: establishing the required ISO 16890 class, measuring usable space, reading pocket geometry correctly, comparing candidates at equal airflow, and the additional checks a retrofit needs before purchase approval.
Define the Required Filtration Level First
Confirm the requested ISO 16890 classification for general ventilation and the scope of the supporting report. Pocket count or a V-shaped arrangement is not evidence of class. If a legacy F7 label appears in the existing specification, compare measured classifications and relevant documents rather than repeating that label alone.
What ePM1, ePM2.5 and ePM10 actually mean
ISO 16890 evaluates general ventilation filters by particulate-matter efficiency. PM1, PM2.5 and PM10 refer to different size fractions rather than separate groups containing particles of one exact size. The percentage is a result for the relevant fraction under the standard assessment.
An ePM1 60% label does not mean that exactly 60% of every one-micrometre particle is captured, nor that all site dust is removed at the same rate. Equally, an ePM1 60% filter is not equivalent to an ePM10 60% filter: the number in the group name describes which fraction was evaluated, not a quality ranking.
Why equal percentages lead to different decisions
An offer stating only 60% efficiency leaves the evaluated group unknown, so request both the group and the percentage when comparing quotations. An ePM10 result alone cannot establish a required fine-particle performance. A report can contain results for several fractions, so compare the same metric for each candidate.
| Label | Question to resolve |
|---|---|
| ISO ePM1 60% | Does this match the required PM1 target? |
| ISO ePM2.5 60% | Are both offers comparing PM2.5 efficiency? |
| ISO ePM10 60% | Does this provide sufficient evidence for the fine-particle target? |
| ISO Coarse | What report and duty define the coarse stage? |
Purchasing example. Two offers have identical dimensions and price. Offer A says ePM1 60%, offer B says ePM10 60%. Do not mark them technically equivalent. Confirm the required group, then ask each supplier for the relevant report and pressure data at the same airflow. These are illustrative labels, not verified performance values for any particular product.
Which group belongs in an air handling unit
Outdoor air quality and the required supply air are considered together rather than applying one class to every office or factory. For a sensitive process, use the applicable project specification. An ePM classification alone does not define a cleanroom class and does not determine whether HEPA filtration is needed; that is a separate decision about the final stage. Once the target is established, examine the airflow and installation data for the proposed element.
How to update a legacy F7 specification
Do not turn an old EN 779 label into a guaranteed ePM equivalent. The relationship between the withdrawn and current classifications is covered in the ISO 16890 and EN 779 comparison. The purchasing task here is to request the proposed product ISO 16890 report together with the approved project target, and to write group, percentage, airflow per element, outside dimensions and seal details into the order line rather than relying on an F7 equivalent claim.
Measure Usable Installation Space
Check pocket length and the space needed to avoid contact with surrounding components during operation. For a compact element, verify frame depth, installation orientation and removal clearance. A filter that passes through the access door may still have the wrong seating interface.
Pocket Count and Length: Six Pockets or Eight?
Pocket count alone does not establish bag filter class, airflow capacity or service life. Compare six- and eight-pocket elements using media area, pocket length, frame, tested classification and pressure loss at the same airflow. Available space inside the unit also limits the choice.
Separate pocket count from classification
Pocket count describes geometry; efficiency class comes from testing. A statement that eight pockets is better than F7 is not a technical comparison, because the two describe different things. Manufacturer tables list classification, pockets, dimensions and airflow as separate fields for that reason. Define the required ISO 16890 target first, then review the geometries that meet it.
Measure pocket length before approving installation
Pocket length affects the clearance needed behind the frame. Check for possible contact with coils, supports and subsequent stages. Passing the element through the door is insufficient, because operation and removal need space as well. Match the existing length to the proposed installation drawing. Folding or compressing longer pockets is not an appropriate substitute for a compatibility review.
Understand the limits of media-area comparisons
Effective media area helps assess geometry, but it should come from the data sheet rather than a guess based on dimensions or pocket count. Compare depth, area, airflow and resistance as a set. With different media, stitching and operating conditions, a larger area alone does not guarantee service life or energy savings.
Simplified calculation. Assume an illustrative element handles 3,600 m³/h, equal to 1 m³/s. With 2 m² of fully used media, average media velocity is approximately 0.5 m/s; with 4 m² it is approximately 0.25 m/s. This describes a geometric relationship only. It does not predict pocket flow distribution, pressure loss, efficiency or life, and doubling area does not establish double service life. The figures are not performance data for a particular product.
Compare six and eight pockets at one operating point
Use the same airflow per element for both candidates. Do not rank initial pressure values quoted at different flows. Request pressure curves, dimensions, frame and seal information, and consider pocket positioning relative to neighbouring components during operation. The variety of bag constructions on the market is itself the reason one pocket count cannot serve every unit.
| Comparison field | Check for both candidates |
|---|---|
| Pocket count | Geometry information, not evidence of class |
| Pocket length | Sufficient operating and removal clearance? |
| Effective media area | Documented on a comparable basis? |
| Initial pressure loss | Quoted at equal airflow per element? |
| Frame and seal | Compatible with seating and retainers? |
Keep the geometry in the approved order line
Record class and standard, width x height x depth, pocket count, frame or flange, seal, airflow and documents. If the specification requires a particular count, purchasing should obtain technical approval before changing it. Where several geometries are suitable, align commercial scope before comparing price, and update the approved part number in the maintenance register after a change.
Compare Performance at the Same Airflow
Assess initial pressure drop at the same airflow per element, and review the fan operating point and permissible system resistance. A low clean-filter resistance or a large media area alone does not guarantee service life or total energy cost: operating conditions and resistance development over time also affect the decision.
Include Maintenance Access in the Decision
Consider access, handling, packaging volume and the existing retention arrangement. Confirm compatibility between retainers and the proposed frame in writing or on a drawing. Retain the reason for accepting one configuration and rejecting another, so future replacement reviews have an engineering basis rather than a remembered preference.
Field example. Two candidates share a face size, but the bag filter needs rear clearance and the compact filter needs different retainers. A unit-price comparison misses those differences. Include installation changes, service access and data at the same airflow in the decision file.
Retrofit: Fan Capacity and Housing Compatibility
A higher filter class or a different construction can affect the whole air handling unit. Fitting the new element into the housing is only one part of the decision: design airflow, fan operation and the sealing interface have to be reviewed together.
Document the current operating condition
Record filtration stages, element count, airflow per element and current pressure readings, including fan settings and control method. Distinguish design airflow from measured site airflow. Without a baseline, the effect of the proposed element is difficult to compare with the previous arrangement.
Assess pressure capacity at system level
Compare filter pressure losses at the required airflow. Ducts, coils and other components also contribute to system resistance, so the technical team should review the fan curve and control limits. Raising fan speed is not automatically appropriate; power, noise and equipment limits have to be considered as well.
Check the housing and sealing interface
Review frame depth, seating surface, gasket side and retaining mechanism on the installation drawing. Parts that contact the media or restrict access can increase handling damage. Selecting a higher class does not establish that leakage around the frame has been addressed, and the interface requires its own review.
Define commissioning before purchase approval
Specify the airflow measurements, pressure records and acceptance checks required after conversion. Necessary tests depend on the application procedure. Update the maintenance register with the approved part and drawing revision, and close the change record before allowing the old part number to remain in automatic replacement purchasing.
Field example. Both elements fit the housing, but their data sheets quote pressure loss at different airflows. Those figures are not directly comparable. Request data at the required design point and combine it with the unit assessment before approving the retrofit.
Practical Checklist
- Required ISO 16890 group and percentage recorded together, with the relevant report.
- Depth, pocket length, free space and service access measured, not assumed from the door opening.
- Pressure drop compared at equal airflow per element, with the fan curve and control limits reviewed.
- Pocket count treated as geometry, with class taken from testing.
- Effective media area taken from the data sheet, alongside depth, airflow and resistance.
- Frame, gasket side and retainer compatibility confirmed on a drawing.
- Commissioning measurements and acceptance records defined before purchase approval.
- Approved part number and drawing revision updated in the register after a change.
Send the manufacturer the unit reference, outside dimensions in mm, required class with its standard, airflow per element, pocket geometry where it is specified and the quantity. Identify missing information so assumptions can be reviewed explicitly; the full request structure is covered in the air filter RFQ guide. Where the housing cross-section does not take a standard module, custom-size manufacturing settles the drawing and tolerance questions first.
Safe Air manufactures bag and compact filters for air handling units, together with the pre-filter stages ahead of them and HEPA final filters where the application requires one. Working through the housing interface with the plant that manufactures the element is what makes a retrofit decision resolvable before the order rather than after delivery.
Request a technical quotation · Our air filter manufacturing in Turkey · Catalogues and technical documents